What to Lead With When Recruits Ask About Payout

contact-icon-image-
Written By:

Jason Mickool

Firm owner talking with a recruit about financial advisor payout and walking them through a written plan for growing the firm

If you own an insurance agency or advisory firm and recruit to grow it, one of the first questions you hear is some version of “What is my payout?” The recruit deserves a clear answer, and the financial advisor payout percentage is only part of what they are deciding.

A payout percentage tells a recruit how revenue is split. It does not tell them how much production your business can help them create, and that production, as much as the percentage, decides what they earn. A recruit who joins you is also choosing which leader to trust with the next several years of a career. Owners who recruit well answer the payout question by showing both the earning opportunity behind the percentage and the career a person can build with them. That answer is easier to give when your recruiting and onboarding system already spells out where the business is going and how people grow in it.

Key Takeaways

Why Leading With Payout Undersells Your Insurance Agency or Advisory Firm

Financial advisor payout is one of the first things a recruit asks about, and it is a fair question. Many owners respond by making compensation and payout the main value they offer. When you do that, your offer amounts to paying the recruit more for the same sale they already make somewhere else. The recruit hears nothing about what your business brings to the client or to them.
“One of the biggest things I see people cheapen in our business is their value.” Jason Mickool, Founder and CEO, Greatness Lab
A recruit also cannot learn much about their future income from a percentage alone. What they earn depends on how much they produce and on what the insurance agency or advisory firm they join does to help them produce more. A financial advisor with strong support from the business can end up earning more than one with a higher percentage and little help. That is the difference between payout and earning opportunity. Payout is the share of revenue a person keeps. Earning opportunity is how much production the business can help that person create, and the income that follows.

Why a Payout Percentage Means Little Without the Production Behind It

You can put the question to any recruit: would you rather have 70 percent of $100,000, or 35 percent of $10 million?

Payout

Production it applies to

Income

70 percent

$100,000

$70,000

35 percent

$10 million

$3.5 million

Two bars drawn to scale showing 70 percent of $100,000 paying $70,000 next to 35 percent of $10 million paying $3.5 million
The recruit at the higher percentage earns far less, because that percentage applies to a much smaller amount of production. The second offer has half the payout and far more earning opportunity. When you walk a recruit through this comparison, you move the conversation away from payout levels and toward what you are building. You make that case best when you have thought bigger about where your own insurance agency or advisory firm is going.

Showing a Recruit the Earning Opportunity

When you walk a recruit through the 70 percent and 35 percent example, their next question is usually what your business does to help people reach that kind of production. You can answer it with three things:
  • What people who joined recently produce now. How the production of financial advisors and insurance agents who joined in recent years has grown, shared with their permission.
  • The support behind that growth. The training, coaching, and help that new people get. At Florida Financial Advisors, the advisory firm led by Greatness Lab founder Jason Mickool, the team trains every morning at 8:30.
  • The math with the recruit’s own numbers. Start with what they produce today at their current percentage. Then show what people like them have gone on to produce on your team, and what your percentage of that would pay.

What Financial Advisors Weigh When Choosing an Advisory Firm or Insurance Agency to Join

Part of a recruit’s decision comes down to trust. A useful question to ask yourself is why a person would want to join your organization, out of all the places they could join.

The recruit is choosing which leader to follow for the next several years of their career. They are also judging whether that leader can help them build a bigger future. As they decide, recruits tend to weigh:

  • How much they trust you with their future.
  • How you answer the questions they ask themselves before joining.
  • Whether you have the qualities that draw top performers to a leader.

Why Recruits Need to Trust a Leader With Their Future

When someone joins your insurance agency or advisory firm, they are placing their future in your hands. Trust at that moment has a specific meaning. The recruit is trusting that, of everyone they could follow, you are the best person to help them reach their potential.

A familiar example comes from college football. Players chose the University of Alabama because they trusted Nick Saban to get them to the NFL. Saban had a record of producing players who were ready for the NFL. For that reason, families sent their sons to him whether or not they liked his personality. Your recruits are making a similar judgment about you, based on what your record suggests you can do for them.

Questions Financial Advisors Ask Before Joining a Leader's Team

Many people have joined an organization and found, 10 years later, that they were no better off. Their income, their future, and their life stayed about the same because of the leader they chose to follow.

Careful recruits want to avoid that outcome. Before they attach their future to someone’s leadership, they ask questions like these. A recruit considering your insurance agency or advisory firm may be asking them about you:

  • Who could help me have a bigger financial future?
  • Who could help steward my talent and potential?
  • Is the person I am joining going anywhere?
  • Is this a consistent, reliable leader I can build my career around?

What Draws Top Financial Advisors to a Leader

Top performers tend to be drawn to leaders who show:
  • Remarkable boldness.
  • A big engine, meaning strong intrinsic motivation.
  • A strong connection with people.
  • The ability to lock in and stay focused on the work.
  • Grit and resilience.

A recruit cannot measure boldness or grit directly. They judge those qualities from what they can see: where you are taking the business, what you have already built, who you have developed, and what they could become with you. Each of those is something you can show a recruit, starting with your vision.

You do not need to be that leader for everyone. It is enough to be that leader for the people you recruit, train, and develop.

What to Lead With Before the Payout Percentage

Before a recruit can trust you, they need something to judge you by, and a payout percentage alone leaves them little to go on. A good place to start is your vision for the business. When you describe it, the recruit can see where the business is going and whether there is a place for them in it. From there, you can show the path of titles they could climb and the evidence that people grow on your team.

Some recruits are experienced insurance agents or financial advisors who want a higher contract. With them, you can also ask for records that back up their track record. Compensation will still come up, and the recruit deserves a clear answer when it does.

Leading With the Vision and Scale of Your Insurance Agency or Advisory Firm

When you describe your vision, you are answering a few questions about your business:
  • How big is it going to be?
  • Who is going to be part of it?
  • What will it look like in the future?

The other part of the work is painting that picture well for someone else. You want a vision big enough that a recruit can see their own future and their own goals inside it.

To make the picture concrete for a recruit, you can show:

  • How big you intend the business to be, and roughly when.
  • Where you plan to grow, such as new offices or new markets.
  • The roles that will exist as the business grows that do not exist today.
  • Where this particular recruit could fit, now and later.

How specific you can be depends on where your business is today. With only a few people, you can still show your written plan to grow, the first steps you have taken, and the roles that come next. As you make recruiting part of everyone’s job, some of the first new roles go to team members who run first interviews.

Why Titles and Recognition Matter Alongside Pay

Early in his career, Greatness Lab founder Jason Mickool learned a lesson that still shapes how he recruits: people do not work for money alone. He describes it as money, marbles, and chalk.
  • Money is pay: salary, commission, and raises.
  • Marbles are rewards, incentives, and trophies.
  • Chalk is recognition, seeing your name in lights.

Money matters, and its effect wears off quickly. In Jason’s experience, the satisfaction from a raise lasts about three weeks. After that, the higher pay is simply what the person earns, and they want another raise or more rewards.

Marbles and chalk work differently. A title someone earned, and the recognition that came with it, can keep meaning something long after a raise has stopped feeling new.

That is the trouble with leading a recruiting conversation with payout. You are competing on the one reward that wears off fastest, and another insurance agency or advisory firm can always offer a higher percentage. A path of titles gives a recruit something to work toward, recognition when they reach it, and room to keep growing. Those are reasons to join and to stay that a competitor cannot match by raising a number.

Showing a Visible Path of Titles and Leadership

Younger recruits often respond to a path into leadership. At Florida Financial Advisors, college students hear about the career as a fast track leadership program. Many students are more excited by that than by an offer to sell insurance. The firm has found that many young people want leadership, want to be part of something bigger, and want to grow.

Each title in the firm’s series comes with a standard a person has to meet. Above financial advisor, the first title is associate manager. It is only a title, and it comes with no extra pay. A person who earns it takes on new responsibilities:

  • Doing certain tasks without the owner, so that they develop on their own.
  • Learning how the business grows, including how to recruit and how to run an interview.

Each title after that asks more of the person. They build a team, help others close business, and eventually lead managers of their own. At Florida Financial Advisors, the path runs through district manager and associate vice president before it reaches the senior titles:

  • Field vice president. Runs an office, including the career preview, the interviews, and the office culture.
  • Regional leader. Oversees several offices that they helped build.
Ladder of titles at Florida Financial Advisors climbing from advisor to associate manager, the titles in between, field vice president, and regional leaders

Showing Recruits Evidence That Financial Advisors Grow on Your Team

A recruit can fairly ask whether the people on your team are better off 10 years after joining. Saban could point to the players he sent to the NFL. You can point to your own evidence, such as:
  • People who started with you and now lead others.
  • The training a new person receives in the first months, and who delivers it.
  • Leaders you promoted from inside the business.

If you are early in building a team, you will have less of this to show. You can still show your own development and the support behind you. That can include who coaches you on leading a team and the training your recruits will go through. It can also include the steps you are taking to move from top producer to firm leader.

Asking Experienced Insurance Agents and Financial Advisors to Back Up Their Track Record

Experienced insurance agents and financial advisors often come to the table asking for a higher contract. Before you agree, you can ask to see last year’s 1099 from their current company. The 1099 documents what the person was paid. If they cannot produce it, or you also want to understand the activity behind those earnings, you can ask for:

  • Their calendar for the last 12 months.
  • The number of Zoom meetings they ran.
  • Their phone call logs and minutes from their phone company.

Activity records show something the 1099 does not. They show how the person works: how many people they see, how often they meet with prospects, and how steady their effort is. With the 1099, the activity records, or both, you have evidence to base the contract on.

This step fits experienced recruits who want a higher contract because of their track record. A newer recruit has no track record to show. With newer recruits, you can focus on the vision, the path, and the evidence that people grow.

How to Answer Questions About Payout and Insurance Agent Commission

Even after you share your vision, recruits will still ask about payout, and they deserve a clear answer. Florida Financial Advisors pays insurance agent commission on a structure the firm defines itself. That structure is part of how the firm keeps its business model profitable as it grows. The firm’s leaders build its margin into the product and service. They then pay on a leveled commission program that they set, so on some sales the firm makes more and on others it makes less.

The payout question is also harder to answer than it sounds:

  • Payout varies. What an insurance agent or financial advisor is paid depends on the product, the client’s age, and the state. A recruit can seldom tell from one percentage what they will earn.
  • Recruits compare what they have heard. Many insurance agents believe they already have the top contract, often because someone told them what the going rate is. When an insurance agent quotes a percentage they heard from someone else, you learn little about what that person earns.
“Every agent that I’ve ever met thinks they have the top contract.” Jason Mickool, Founder and CEO, Greatness Lab
When you answer the payout question, you can cover:
  1. How your compensation is structured, in plain terms.
  2. What the percentage applies to and what drives the amount, such as product and activity.
  3. The earning opportunity: what your business does to grow the recruit’s production, and the vision they would be part of.

Owners who have written down their recruiting system, from sourcing candidates and running group interviews to building a compensation ladder, can answer each of these from what they already have.

Writing Your Recruiting Offer on One Page

Once your recruiting offer is written down, you have something specific to lead with when a recruit asks about payout. You can fit each part on a single page and fill it in with prompts like these:
  • Vision: How big will the business be, and roughly when? Where will it grow, and who will be part of it?
  • Earning opportunity: What does your business do to grow a new person’s production? How has the production of people who joined in recent years grown?
  • Path: What are the titles, what standard earns each one, and who has reached them?
  • Evidence: Who has grown on your team, and what training did they receive?
  • Proof you ask for: What do you ask experienced recruits to show before a higher contract: last year’s 1099, activity records, or both?
  • Your answer to the payout question: How is your compensation structured, in plain terms?
With the page filled in, you can answer the payout question clearly and then show the recruit the earning opportunity and the career behind it.

Recruiting Advisors and Agents With the Business You Are Building

When a recruit asks about payout, they are also deciding whom to trust with the next several years of their career. A bigger percentage of an unknown amount of production is a weak offer on its own. A stronger offer shows what your business can help the person produce and become: your vision, your path of titles, and the people who have grown on your team. When you then explain your compensation clearly, the recruit has what they need to decide whether you are the leader to follow.

Build a Recruiting Offer Worth Joining

Tell us how you answer the payout question today and who you want to recruit. We will talk through your vision, your path of titles, and ways Greatness Lab could help you build the recruiting system behind them.

Start a Conversation

Questions Owners Ask About Financial Advisor Payout and Recruiting

Should an insurance agency or advisory firm owner lead with compensation when recruiting financial advisors and insurance agents?

Compensation deserves a clear answer, and a payout percentage should not carry the entire recruiting offer. Owners can also show recruits the earning opportunity behind the percentage: what the business does to help people produce more, where the business is going, the career path available, and evidence that people have grown there.

What do financial advisors look for when choosing an advisory firm or insurance agency to join?

When financial advisors join an advisory firm or insurance agency, they are trusting that its leader is the best person to develop their potential. Before joining, careful recruits ask whether a leader can help them build a bigger financial future and steward their talent. They also ask whether the leader is going anywhere, and whether the leader is consistent and reliable.

Is a higher financial advisor payout always better?

A higher financial advisor payout means more income only when the production behind it is similar or larger. For example, 70 percent of $100,000 is $70,000, and 35 percent of $10 million is $3.5 million. A financial advisor whose advisory firm helps them produce more can earn a lower percentage and still take home more income.

How can an insurance agency or advisory firm owner check an experienced recruit's track record before offering a higher contract?

The owner can ask an experienced insurance agent or financial advisor to show last year’s 1099 from their current company. The 1099 documents what the recruit was paid. If the recruit cannot provide it, or the owner wants to understand the activity behind those earnings, the owner can ask for the recruit’s calendar for the last 12 months, the number of Zoom meetings they ran, and their phone call logs. Those records show how active the recruit has been and how they work.

How can an insurance agency or advisory firm owner recruit people who have never worked in insurance?

Owners can present the opportunity as a leadership path, with titles and a standard for each step. At Florida Financial Advisors, college students hear about the career as a fast track leadership program, because many are more excited by that than by an offer to sell insurance. At that firm, a person who earns the first title, associate manager, starts doing certain tasks without the owner and learning how to recruit and interview.

About the Authors

Jason Mickool, Founder and CEO of Greatness Lab

Jason Mickool built Florida Financial Advisors from a kitchen table conversation into a national advisor enterprise. It grew to dozens of locations across more than a dozen states, and he completed a nine-figure transaction. Today he brings that operating experience to Greatness Lab. There he coaches insurance and financial business owners who want to build, scale, and exit on their own terms. He is the author of Built to Lead, Built to Scale. Connect with Jason Mickool on LinkedIn or at jasonmickool.com.

Coach Micheal Burt, Performance Coach

Coach Micheal Burt is a performance coach, best-selling author, and founder of The Greatness Factory in Nashville, Tennessee. A former championship basketball coach, he teaches the Prey Drive and Monster mindset frameworks to business owners and financial advisors. He partners with Greatness Lab as its Greatness Executive Coach. Connect with Coach Micheal Burt on LinkedIn or at coachburt.com.

Related Topic

Owner mapping an insurance agency business model on a whiteboard, showing how products move from manufacturers through advisors to client households

Many owners of insurance agencies and advisory firms reach a point where they are working harder than ever without seeing the same return from that effort. They can improve their

Newer team member helping an agency recruit insurance agents by leading a first interview with a candidate at a small office table

If you own an insurance agency or advisory firm and want to grow beyond what you can produce on your own, at some point you need to bring in other

Agency owner writing an insurance agency value proposition as one sentence that names a skill and the problem it solves

Sooner or later, someone across the table will ask what makes your business different. It might be a possible partner, an investor or buyer, or a recruit deciding where to

Ready to Experience
Interdependent Growth?

Schedule a conversation to explore if the Greatness Lab community is right for you.

Scale Without Surrender
9 simple questions about your practice. Most financial advisors and insurance brokers can’t answer them. Can you?
The Practice Check-Up — takes 10 minutes